Table I

A federalist view on the EU

orientation of citizens

support of citizens for integration; EP as the focus point for citizen's appreciation; shift of loyalties

attribute of the EU system

EU as a democratic and parliamentary state-like political system; EP as the main democratic organ

EU policies

growing Europeanization of policies; leading role of the EP in policy-making

EU institutions

EP as the democratic centre of the EU system; truly legislative body

material interests

growing interest of the public; EP as important centre of interest-mediation

symbols, narratives

European constitution; European citizenship; common values and symbols (flag, anthem)

Table II

An interstate (realist) view on the EU

orientation of the citizens

EU perception mediated through national orientations; low support; nation states as main focus of the European peoples

attribute of the EU

union of states; not a european polity; limited capacity to command assent; only supplementary legitimacy by the EP

policies

low politics; unspecific and diffuse perception of EU policies, though with increasing importance

institutions

European institutions are only oflimited importance; Council and European Council as centres of decision-making

material interests

directed towards the national polities and their institutions

symbols, narrative

actually non-existent; superseded by national identification

Table III

The Fusion Thesis

orientation of the citizens

mixed perception; neither strong support nor rejection; low interest with a high range of indifferent tolerance

attributes of the EU system

mixed polity with mixed sources of legitimacy: national and European; complexity

EU policies

Europeanization; growing importance of EU policies acompanied by a certain preservation of national competencies

EU institutions

The EP as one actor among others, however with a special feature: direct democratic election; beneath other organs on different levels; interaction in formal and informal ways

material interests

wide range of European, national, regional, local and functional actors with specific interests and patterns of representation; basically: the rational interest of modern welfare and service states on fusion

symbols, narratives

only slightly developing; not a driving force of a mixed polity, but neither one that will stop or revert the process

Graph 1

Graph 2


©1997 by Wessels/Diedrichs
arranged by MN, 22.3.1997