Table 1

Coding Sources (in percent)

Source \ Country BBC CSM ECON FT Le Monde Reuters SDZ Xinhua other N
Belgium 2.22 0.19 3.71 7.11 0.00 56.63 0.00 3.67 26.48 2617
France 0.21 0.34 0.45 3.14 6.77 54.42 0.00 4.20 30.46 15295
FRG 0.12 0.65 0.08 1.77 0.05 71.62 4.82 6.66 14.21 7503
mean 0.85 0.39 1.41 4.01 2.28 60.89 1.61 4.85 23.72
BBC
British Broadcast Cooperation
CSM
Christian Science Monitor
ECON
Economist
FT
Financial Times
SDZ
Süddeutsche Zeitung

Table 2

Descriptive Statistics for Biyearly European Protest Counts (N=32)

Variable Mean Standard Deviation Variance Minimum Maximum
Belgian protest (total) 14.25 25.15 632.32 0 100
Belgian protest (farmers) .88 1.60 2.56 0 6
Belgian protest (without farmers) 13.38 24.76 613.15 0 96
French protest (total) 21.69 30.59 935.96 0 120
French protest (farmers) 13.03 23.21 538.81 0 108
French protest (without farmers) 8.66 14.05 197.33 0 62
German protest (total) 2.97 3.84 14.74 0 15
German protest (farmers) 1.78 3.44 11.85 0 15
German protest (without farmers) 1.19 2.13 4.54 0 9

Table 3

Number of European protest events and rank-order of event frequency (1980-1995: six-month aggregation)

Period France Belgium Germany sequence of event frequency
1980-1 2
[1]
0
[2]
0
[2]
France-Belgium-Germany
France-Germany-Belgium
1980-2 0
[2]
0
[2]
5
[1]
Germany-Belgium-France
Germany-France-Belgium
1981-1 2
[2]
33
[1]
0
[3]
Belgium-France-Germany
1981-2 1
[-]
1
[-]
1
[-]
1982-1 10
[2]
100
[1]
0
[3]
Belgium-France-Germany
1982-2 1
[1]
0
[2]
0
[3]
France-Belgium-Germany
France-Germany-Belgium
1983-1 21
[1]
7
[2]
1
[3]
France-Belgium-Germany
1983-2 3
[2]
73
[1]
1
[3]
Belgium-France-Germany
1984-1 43
[1]
7
[2]
1
[3]
France-Belgium-Germany
1984-2 3
[1]
1
[2]
0
[3]
France-Belgium-Germany
1985-1 34
[1]
1
[2]
0
[3]
France-Belgium-Germany
1985-2 6
[1]
1
[2]
1
[2]
France-Belgium-Germany
France-Germany-Belgium
1986-1 2
[2]
0
[3]
4
[1]
Germany-France-Belgium
1986-2 16
[1]
0
[2]
0
[2]
France-Belgium-Germany
France-Germany-Belgium
1987-1 7
[2]
3
[3]
15
[1]
Germany-France-Belgium
1987-2 0
[2]
1
[1]
0
[2]
Belgium-France-Germany
Belgium-Germany-France
1988-1 11
[1]
1
[3]
7
[2]
France-Germany-Belgium
1988-2 0
[-]
0
[-]
0
[-]
1989-1 5
[1]
3
[2]
3
[2]
France-Belgium-Germany
France-Germany-Belgium
1989-2 1
[1]
0
[2]
0
[2]
France-Belgium-Germany
France-Germany-Belgium
1990-1 30
[1]
2
[3]
10
[2]
France-Germany-Belgium
1990-2 8
[1]
6
[2]
1
[3]
France-Belgium-Germany
1991-1 3
[2]
6
[1]
0
[3]
Belgium-France-Germany
1991-2 52
[1]
2
[3]
3
[2]
France-Germany-Belgium
1992-1 120
[1]
5
[2]
4
[3]
France-Belgium-Germany
1992-2 100
[1]
14
[2]
6
[3]
France-Belgium-Germany
1993-1 91
[1]
43
[2]
9
[3]
France-Belgium-Germany
1993-2 41
[1]
41
[1]
7
[3]
France-Belgium-Germany
Belgium-France-Germany
1994-1 20
[1]
4
[2]
4
[2]
France-Belgium-Germany
France-Germany-Belgium
1994-2 7
[3]
13
[1]
10
[2]
Belgium-Germany-France
1995-1 21
[2]
53
[1]
1
[3]
Belgium-France-Germany
1995-2 34
[1]
2
[2]
1
[3]
France-Belgium-Germany

The first row denotes the number of protest events and the numbers in paranthesis in the second row indicate the rank-order of event frequency among the three countries.

Table 4

Sequence count of European protest

Sequence count all protesters farmers non-farmers
France-Belgium-Germany 17 16 11
France-Germany-Belgium 10 15 3
Belgium-France-Germany 7 1 12
Belgium-Germany-France 2 1 5
Germany-Belgium-France 1 1 1
Germany-France-Belgium 3 3 1

Table 5

Crosstabulation of relative event frequency and relative degree of territorial centralization (for all protest events)

Observed Count
Expected Value
France
(high)
Belgium
(medium)
Germany
(low)
Row Total
1 20
10.3
8
10.3
3
10.3
31
34.4%
2 9
12.7
17
12.7
12
12.7
38
42.2%
3 1
7.0
5
7.0
15
7.0
21
23.3%
Column Total 30
33.3%
30
33.3%
30
33.3%
90
100%

Number of Missing Observations: 6 Somers' D .50593 Chi-Square 32.21028 (4 DF; significance: .00000)

Table 6

Analysis of Variance For All Protest Events

Source degrees of freedom Sums of Squares Mean Square F-ratio Probability
Territorial Centralization 2 5622.02 2811.01 5.5286 0.0054
Error 93 47285.9 508.451
Total 95 52907.96

Appendix

Table A1

Crosstabulation of relative event frequency and relative degree of territorial centralization (only farmer protest)

Observed Count
Expected Value
France
(high)
Belgium
(medium)
Germany
(low)
Row Total
1 21
8.7
1
8.7
4
8.7
26
33.3%
2 4
12.3
17
12.3
16
12.3
37
47.4%
3 1
5.0
8
5.0
6
5.0
15
19.2%
Column Total 26
33.3%
26
33.3%
26
33.3%
78
100.0%

Number of Missing Observations: 18 Somers' D .43442 Chi-Square 40.53264 (significance: .00000)

Table A2

Analysis of Variance For Farmer Protest

Source degrees of freedom Sums of Squares Mean Square F-ratio Probability
Territorial Centralization 2 2935.02 1467.51 7.9580 0.0006
Error 93 17149.9 184.408
Total 95 20085.0

Table A3

Crosstabulation of relative event frequency and relative degree of territorial centralization (all non-farmer protest)

Observed Count
Expected Value
France
(high)
Belgium
(medium)
Germany
(low)
Row Total
1 14
8.7
11
8.7
1
8.7
26
34.7%
2 9
10.3
14
10.3
8
10.3
31
41.3%
3 2
6.0
0
6.0
16
6.0
18
24.0%
Column Total 25
33.3%
25
33.3%
25
33.3%
75
100%

Number of Missing Observations: 21 Somers' D .51947 Chi-Square 38.02564 (significance: .00000)

Table A4

Analysis of Variance For Non-Farmer Protest

Source degrees of freedom Sums of Squares Mean Square F-ratio Probability
Territorial Centralization 2 2070.19 1035.09 4.1116 0.0195
Error 93 23412.97 251.752
Total 95 25483.16

Figure 1

Temporal changes and the comparative degree of (territorial) centralization

Fig 1
©1998 by Reising
formated and tagged by MN, 17.7.1998